FHIR vs. C-CDA: What Are These Two Formats and How Do They Compare?

January 26, 2022

Particle Health Team

A high-level overview of the two common formats for exchanging medical records.

Your test results, visit notes, and vital signs are all clinical documents. FHIR and C-CDA are the two primary data formats used to electronically share these medical records.

FHIR vs. C-CDA Basics

	C-CDA	FHIR
Full Name:	Consolidated Clinical Document Architecture	Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources
Exchanges Full Patient Records:	Yes	Yes
Easy Extraction of Specific Data Points:	No - specialized parsing needed to extract individual data points.	Yes - easy to search and separate every aspect of patient encounters.
Best for Organizations That:	• Require a quick implementation time. • Prefer to receive all individual data files. • Already use a CDA-compatible system.	• Have well-defined use cases. • Know which specific data elements (like medications) they need. • Previously worked with healthcare data (especially JSON-based FHIR).

FHIR vs. C-CDA Tech Specs

	C-CDA	FHIR
Human-Readable Output:	Yes	Yes
Data Formats:	XML (primarily); PNGs and PDFs also occur	JSON
Particle API Paradigm:	Downloadable via REST¹	Follows REST FHIR R4 Spec
Developer Ease of Use:	Easy to implement, but harder to parse.	More intensive to implement, but easier to parse.
Forward Compatible:	Being phased out - Particle can transform into FHIR format.	Largely codified as new standard.
Particle Stores Data For:	2 days	30 days

FHIR vs. C-CDA History

	C-CDA	FHIR
Meets Meaningful Use and Patient Access Standards:	Yes	Yes
First Normative Release:	2011	2019
Date Required in Health IT:	2014	2022
Health API and EHR Support:	Universal	Sometimes
Regulatory Basis:	HITECH Act / Meaningful Use Rule	Cures Act / Anti-Information Blocking Rule / TEFCA
Supported by Particle's API:	Yes	Yes

FHIR vs. C-CDA Similarities

Both FHIR and C-CDA:

Assist with Cures Act anti-information blocking compliance, although C-CDA is a less comprehensive solution.
Are developed by Health Level 7 (HL7), the standards development organization dedicated to digital health interoperability.
Evolve by consensus via HL7.
Support structured and unstructured data.
Combine information into standardized document types.
Are open source. ❤️

Example C-CDA Document

CCDA summary of care example — Beginning of a C-CDA Summary of Care XML document (using synthetic data, of course).

Example FHIR Resource

FHIR medication resource example — Beginning of a FHIR medication resource (with synthetic data).

To sum up, C-CDA is a markup standard that creates large bundles of patient data. FHIR includes additional API elements that allow for unbundling of patient data.

Particle’s tools - including our API, industry-leading record locator 🌎, and stunningly reliable document converter ✨ - add additional functionality to both data formats.

These formats are enabling long-sought interoperability goals, pulling together data from smart devices to labs to hospitals. Explore them both to get the healthcare data you need!

‍

^{1. Natively SOAP, but Particle supports an easier RESTful API.↩}

About the author

Particle Health Team

Most Read Stories

See for yourself

Tech Talk: Why Choose an API as a Product?

We know what APIs are, and what they do. So why choose an API as a product? APIs have become largely ubiquitous in the tech landscape, and for good reason. While there are alternatives, it's important to understand why we don’t choose them. Check out Part 2 of our three part miniseries on APIs.

Particle Health Team

Dec 10, 2020

What is C-CDA?

This widespread data format paved the way for health record interoperability.

Particle Health Team

Feb 10, 2022

Meaningful Use and the HITECH Act

Electronic health records are great, but it’s the way that you use them that matters. Meaningful Use, a concept from 2009’s HITECH Act, incentivized healthcare organizations to actually utilize the digital health tools which they purchased.

Particle Health Team

Sep 15, 2022